Sunday, October 10, 2010

Strategy: Reinforcing Effort and Providing Recognition

Reading Research Reflection
Classroom Instruction Chapter 4
Strategy: Reinforcing Effort and Providing Recognition

Part 1: Summary
            Chapter four of Classroom Instruction deals with the importance of reinforcing effort and providing recognition to our students.  This chapter is somewhat different than the others because it deals with instructional techniques that address students’ attitudes and beliefs rather than cognitive skills.  As adults, we know that effort ultimately pays off with enhanced achievement.  Because of this, we have a motivational tool that we can apply to any situation.  Not all students are aware of this fact.  We as teachers need to explain and exemplify this concept to them.  Luckily, we can teach them to operate under the assumption that effort pays off.  A good way to do this is through stories about famous people who never gave up.  Also, having the students track their effort and subsequent achievement is a powerful tool to show the link.  Going hand in hand with reinforcing effort is providing recognition.  Recognition is not the same as praise or rewards, which have been shown to sometimes decrease intrinsic motivation.  It should be an abstract and symbolic acknowledgement that a student has attained specific performance goals.  This can be a powerful motivator.  Students need to learn that the harder they try, the more successful they are.  When they are successful we as teachers need to provide recognition to stimulate their motivation.
Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class
            Chapter four of Classroom Instruction and chapter one of The Art and Science of Teaching both discuss the strategies of reinforcing effort and providing recognition.  Chapter one lists formative assessments as a good way for students to observe the increase in their learning over time.  This is just another way they can actually see the relationship between how hard they work and how much they learn.  Regarding providing recognition, chapter one had some interesting additions.  Although tangible rewards, by definition, decrease intrinsic motivation; abstract, verbal acknowledgement of achievement can increase students’ interest and attitudes about a particular task or concept.  As stated many times before, high interest and positive attitudes about a concept will lead to increased achievement. 
Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
            This week in my clinical was Homecoming Week and the activities in the classroom have been a little abnormal.  I don’t think I have seen a typical day.  I am interested to see how the teacher interacts with the students when it comes to reinforcing effort and providing recognition.  I think I have a good grip on how to reinforce effort.  I am a firm believer in trying your hardest and being able to see the results.  I think that will be somewhat easy to teach my students.  On the other hand, I’m afraid I have an idealistic view of how to provide recognition and I’m not sure how appropriate it is for high school students.  I think I may be a little too “Susie Sunshine.”  I never want what I say to undermine their achievement.  I don’t want to praise them for something too easy and lower their perception of their ability.  I hope that watching the teacher in the classroom for a few more days will provide me with some good examples. 

2 comments:

  1. I think you're right. It is detrimental to students if the type of recognition is constant to the point of possibly being too position or cheery. I can remember one teacher in high school who I thought was giving great feedback at the beginning of the year started to sound like a broken record by the end of the year. The praise just didn’t seem to work after five, six, or a hundred times. Another teacher seemed to engrain in his head to give the “appropriate response” to students. For example, he’d say “good question” after every question or "nice job" after every statement. It became obvious that he hadn’t thought about what we were saying. Other than that, all I can recommend is personalize your feedback. Students can identify better with a teacher’s personal style over that of a cookie cutter response.

    ReplyDelete
  2. My school was also participating in homecoming events the few weeks that we have been in our placements. I think of the opportunities we have in regard to reinforcing effort and providing recognition and tend to lean toward verbal praise more often because of the immediate response and effects it has on students. Although it seems that I to remember those teachers that utilized the technique too often and depending on the tone of voice and situation, seemed uneffective to some. Creativity in how you use these techniques is very helpful and keeps the students interested.

    ReplyDelete