Monday, November 15, 2010

Generating and Testing Hypotheses

Part 1: Summary
            Chapter nine of Classroom Instruction deals with generating and testing hypotheses.  This is one of the most powerful and analytic of cognitive operations.  It involves the application of knowledge.  Two generalizations can guide the use of this strategy.  (1)There are many tasks to guide students through generating and testing hypotheses.  They can be inductive- drawing new conclusions through observations we make about information we know or are presented with or deductive- using a general rule to make a prediction about the future.  Some common ways to employ hypothesis generation and testing are: systems analysis- where students predict what will happen if an aspect of a system were changed, problem solving- where students use their understanding of concepts related to the problem and consider different approaches to a solution, historical investigation- where students construct plausible scenarios for events from the past where there is no general agreement, invention- where students improve or respond to a particular situation with an idea, experimental inquiry- where students apply their understanding of content to predict what might happen in a similar situation, and decision making- where students examine hypothetical situations and select the best or worst example of something.(2)Students should be asked to explain their hypotheses and conclusions.  This meta-analysis helps them deepen their understanding of the principles they are applying. Generating and testing hypotheses is a basic cognitive skill that applies to many tasks in many subject areas.
Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class
            Chapter nine of Classroom Instruction and chapter four of The Art and Science of Teaching both discuss the strategy of generating and testing hypotheses.  The Art and Science of Teaching goes into much more detail about units that can be designed around this strategy, where Classroom Instruction gave information more about simple tasks or assignments.  Chapter four first teaches you how to explain to students about support and then provides four descriptions of specific ways to require students to generate and test hypotheses.  These are: inquiry tasks, problem-solving tasks, decision-making tasks, and investigation tasks.  Although there is clearly overlap, I think The Art and Science of Teaching provides more useful information for actually executing this strategy.
            Part3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
            I ended up teaching two units in my clinical.  To open the second unit (on cell transport) I had an egg demonstration for the class.  I had two eggs that the calcium carbonate had been dissolved and I placed one in a beaker of water and one in a beaker of corn syrup.  The results wouldn’t be seen until the next day, so I had the students make predictions as to what would happen to each egg.  I made sure to tell them that there were no wrong answers but they needed to be prepared to explain to me why they hypothesized as they did.  At the time I thought this was important to ensure that they actually thought about the demonstration and didn’t just write down nonsense.  I see now that in addition to that I was also helping them to deepen their understanding of the principles they were applying.  Once we observed what actually did happen to the eggs we had a class discussion where students explained whether their prediction was confirmed or disconfirmed and what they think caused they results.

Monday, November 8, 2010

Cues, Questions, and Advance Organizers

Reading Research Reflection
Classroom Instruction Chapter 10
Strategy: Cues, Questions, and Advance Organizers

Part 1: Summary

            Chapter ten of Classroom Instruction discusses cues, questions, and advance organizers- ways to activate prior knowledge.  Cues and questions are previews about what students are about to experience.  There are a few generalizations that can guide the use of cues and questions.  Cues and questions should focus on what is important rather than what is interesting, higher level questions produce a deeper learning, wait time increases the depth of students’ answers, and questions are effective when asked before a learning experience.  Advance organizers are another way to help students use their background knowledge to learn new information.  They are introductory materials presented at a higher level of abstraction, generality, and inclusiveness than the information presented after it.  They are designed to bridge the gap between what the learner already knows and what he needs to know before he can successfully learn the task at hand.  In addition to the generalizations for cues and questions, advance organizers are most useful with information that is not well organized and different types produce different results.  The different types include: expository, narrative, skimming, and illustrated.  Student achievement can be greatly enhanced by helping students think about new knowledge before experiencing it and cues, questions, and advance organizers are great ways to facilitate this type of thinking.

Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class

            Chapter ten of Classroom Instruction and chapter two of The Art and Science of Teaching both discuss cues, questions, and advance organizers.  The Art and Science of Teaching mentions these strategies as more preview-oriented.  They are particularly helpful for students who do not have a great deal of background knowledge.  These strategies can give students a heads-up as to where to focus their attention.  They establish expectations for the students.

Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests

            I find myself using a lot of questions and cues while in my clinical.  I think it is very important for me to come up with a handful of questions before class in my lesson planning, otherwise it is difficult for me to make sure they are on the higher order.  I notice when I don’t prepare enough questions ahead of time the ones I come up with on the spot are more recall than critical thinking.  Recently I began my class with a preview question about gargling salt water to ease the pain of a sore throat.  The lecture/discussion was on osmosis and diffusion and I really think it helped the students to have a focus at the beginning.  I asked the question, taught the lesson, and then we discussed the question as a class.  My students seemed a little more involved than other times.  I could really see the benefit of preview questioning.  With the teaching I’m doing right now, the information is very organized already so I haven’t had the need for an advance organizer.  While I was observing, the teacher showed a movie about evolution and I can see how an advance organizer may have been helpful for the students.  It would have pinpointed what they were supposed to learn from the film and organized the information into a more manageable format.