Monday, September 20, 2010

Strategy: Summarizing and Note Taking

Part 1: Summary
            Chapter three of Classroom Instruction deals with the topics of summarizing and note taking.  Both of these study skills require students to refine information in a parsimonious form.  They allow students to identify and understand the most important aspects of what they are learning.  There are three generalizations about summarizing effectively: students must delete, substitute, and keep some information; students must analyze the information at a deep level; and students must be aware of the explicit structure of information.  There are a handful of ways to practice summarizing in the classroom.  The rule based strategy is where students follow a set of rules regarding deleting and substituting information.  Summary frames utilize the structure of information to summarize.  And reciprocal teaching is when a student leader summarizes questions, clarifies, and predicts about a particular passage.  In order for these strategies to work the teacher needs to first demonstrate them in some detail.  There are a few generalizations about the second topic, note taking: verbatim notes are the least effective, notes are a work in progress, notes should be used as study guides, and the more notes taken the better.  Teacher-prepared notes easily show students a model.  Because not every student enjoys taking notes the same way there are different formats.  These include: informal outline, webbing, and combination.  These two strategies are some of the most important because they are tools for helping students understand the information they are learning.
Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class
            Chapter three of Classroom Instruction and hapter two of The Art and Science of Teaching both discuss summarizing and note taking.  Both texts stress the importance of students differentiating between what is important information and what is supplemental.  Both texts also address the idea of students using these strategies to make the information their own.  Just like Classroom Instruction, The Art and Science of Teaching suggests using the combination form of note taking.  The left hand side of the page is reserved for written notes, the right hand side is for graphical representation, and the bottom is for summary statements of what the student has learned.  This is a particularly effective method of note taking because it makes the student stop and consider and process the information a second and third time.
Part3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
            I noticed something very important as I was reading this chapter.  In the rule-based strategy, students must delete trivial and redundant material, substitute superordinate terms for lists, and select or invent a topic sentence.  None of this can be done if they don’t have the knowledge base about the content.  You can’t substitute one general term for a list of things if you don’t know what category they fall into.  Also, without the appropriate knowledge a student can’t determine if two items are redundant.  They wouldn’t know they were the same thing.  I can see that summarizing is a later step in the teaching process because the background information has to be there.  Also, summarizing could be a great formative assessment tool.  If my students do a poor job summarizing something I feel they should know well, it tells me that I need to go back and re-teach.  Obviously there has been some sort of information breakdown.

2 comments:

  1. Ironically enough, I like your summary about summary giving in your application section. You really break it down into very usable material. It's kind of like the chapter was a king size Snickers and your application was like a fun size Snickers: gets the job done with same great taste!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that you bring out a very powerful point with summarizing. If students do not do well, you can use that as an indicator for having to re-teach the information. If I may suggest, sometimes re-teaching immediately (soon after receiving the substandard summaries) is not always desirable. Sometimes students will assimilate the material slowly, so I would suggest perhaps covering the next unit, then revisiting the topic again. This allows both you and the students to approach it with a different perspective, and the outlook for the students won’t seem as bleak. You may also be impressed that after some time has passed that students have actually acquired some of the information after letting it sit for a while.

    ReplyDelete