Monday, August 30, 2010

Strategy Reflection: Classroom Instruction Chapter 8

Strategy: Setting Objectives and Providing Feedback

Part 1: Summary of reading
Chapter eight of Classroom Instruction deals with the importance of setting objectives and providing feedback to enhance student learning. Goal setting is the process of establishing a direction for learning. Research on goal setting has shown that instructional goals narrow what students focus on, instructional goals should not be too specific, and students should personalize the goals set by the teacher-adapting them to their own needs and desires. Feedback, the other topic discussed in the chapter, is considered by many to be the most powerful strategy a teacher can use to enhance achievement. Feedback should be corrective in nature, meaning it should explain what is accurate and what is inaccurate regarding the student’s responses. It should also be timely. Feedback is most effective when given immediately after a test. Providing feedback in terms of knowledge and skill is better than providing a percentage score. Students should monitor their own progress in addition to the feedback provided by the teacher. Setting objectives and providing feedback are underused strategies, but this chapter provides many options for incorporating them into instruction.

Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in the class
Chapter eight of Classroom Instruction and Design Question one in The Art and Science of Teaching discuss setting goals and providing feedback. Both texts stress the importance of keeping goals general and flexible. There is a difference between activities/ assignments (behavioral objectives) and learning goals. Both texts also suggest having students identify personal learning goals. This will lead to more engagement from the student. While the act of providing feedback is discussed in Classroom Instruction, the way to go about tracking student progress, in order to have feedback to give, is discussed in The Art and Science of Teaching. The rubrics and scales provided give teachers a way to determine whether the student has demonstrated the knowledge. Without this information, the teacher would have no feedback for the student. For these reasons, I feel the content overlaps in both texts.

Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
Since I am not currently teaching, I cannot relate this reading to what I do in the classroom, but I can store it away for use when I do teach. Goal setting is something I was never exposed to in school, but its benefits are clear. Knowing the desired outcome for a unit at the start will give the learning a direction. I feel it is easier to stay on course when you know what the end point is. Having students tailor the general objectives to personal ones for themselves provides an individual investment in the unit. It can be easily seen whether these goals have been met. The section on feedback sheds new light on the topic. Of course I received grades in school, but to what extent did I learn anything from them? A simple letter grade will not increase my knowledge of the subject; it tells me nothing about my learning. As a teacher, criterion-based feedback must be my main concern. This way my students will know where they stand relative to a specific target of knowledge or skill as opposed to where they stand in relationship to other students. I must also be prompt in providing feedback. I want my students to remember what they were tested on and learn from my comments. Otherwise, the whole point of feedback is lost.

2 comments:

  1. Not to begin by disagreeing, but I think we have all been exposed to a certain degree of goal setting in school. I went through my schooling mostly in the 1980s, and I can remember even back in grade school receiving checks, check minuses, and check pluses for different criteria or goals. Whether the goals to received favorable marks were by treating the teacher with respect, learning the ABCs, or even earning a desirable grade in general science or English in middle and high schools, they were still goals. The grades demonstrated how well you met the goals set for you, whether you knew the goals or not. Without these grades or goals, student would be aimlessly acquiring information without striving for at least the letter grade the information mastery could represent.

    On the other hand, I think you have really understood the concept of goal setting as it can be applied in today’s classroom. Specifically where you stated: “Having students tailor the general objectives to personal ones for themselves provides an individual investment in the unit.” The most important aspect is the individual investment that a student should own during their learning process. In this case, the students can, and will, be able to provide much of their own feedback by how thoroughly they learned their own personalized goal. Of course, that does not replace the teacher recognition that many students desire, but their own feeling of being an expert on their little niche of information will make them feel very good and validate the importance and longevity of the lesson.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think you have trully grasped the concept of goal setting and then providing feedback to provide an ultimate impact on student learning. I liked how you talked about goal setting and tailoring objectives to students themselves, in turn giving them incentive in their "investment." I too think that would motivate students to focus and work harder to reach their goals.

    ReplyDelete